'In Plain Sight' play confronts Mother and Baby Home legacy
Thomas Lyons
Towards the end of the theatrical piece ‘In Plain Sight’ performer Camille O’Sullivan commences laying out evidence identification markers. As she does so her co-performer, Noelle Brown, recaps some details of the crimes explored over the previous 65 minutes.
Any uncertainty that this performance was a crime drama would have dissipated with the positioning of the tented number cards.
The crime scene placards were placed on the files of The Commission of Investigation’s report into the Mother and Baby homes, on letters from Mothers Superior and on the architectural models of Sean Ross Abbey, Castlepollard and Bessborough.
It’s not a play in the traditional manner. It is a story that has yet to end. Told in fragments, told with an actor’s dispassion and a survivor’s passion, it covers as serious an issue as you can possibly get, yet is flecked with a dark humour.
Noelle is angry, but not the anger of undirected rage, it’s an anger with a honed sharpness. An anger whetted on a stone of state indifference. An anger at a state crime against children. An anger at the Commission of Investigation report into Irish Mother and Baby Homes.
Between 1922 and 1998 around 9,000 children died in the 18 Irish Mother and Baby Homes that were investigated. Roughly 1 in 7 of the children who entered the institutions died there. That was around double the infant mortality rate of the general population during the same period.
Mortality was heavily concentrated in the decades before 1960, peaking in the 1930s and 1940s, when institutional rates climbed up to four times higher than the national average. It reached 30% to 40% overall, and up to 75% in specific homes like Bessborough.
Bessborough was where Noelle was born. The Commission only examined 14 mother-and-baby homes and four county homes. It published the ‘final’ report following a five-year investigation. Among the details in the report was the conclusion that there was no evidence of forced adoptions.
During the performance, Noelle and Camille discuss the design and history of the institutions and highlight the environments experienced by the women and children. The narrative incorporates reflections on original architecture, modern excerpts from government policy, and 100-year-old correspondence from the religious orders who ran these buildings for more than 70 years.
The interplay between Church and state of the time can be difficult to comprehend for modern audiences. The use of the name ‘Mother and Baby’ was itself a deception. Mother evokes a certain image, an image that would run contrary to the fact that many of the mothers were just children themselves.
Noelle told the audience that the extracts from her testimony given to the Commission of Investigation contain at least 10 glaring inaccuracies. Her half hour submission was distilled down to 96 words.
The piece featured original songs performed by Camille alongside re-enactments of Noelle’s campaigning for Justice. At one point Camille sang the 96 words, transforming state homogenisation into something beautiful.
This recounting of out inconvenient history was directed by Veronica Coburn, with sound and original music by Denis Clohessy and lighting by Bill Woodland. The power of the sound and lighting design had to be experienced to be understood.
In Plain Sight is a unique theatre event. By staging it in the heart of a community that lived cheek by jowl with one of those misnamed ‘care institutes’, the production brings the terrible hidden story to light.
This story is something the state just want to go away; something they hope the public will forget over time, like eVoting machines or PPARS or the cost of the new children’s hospital. The difference is that those were just money, while this is about human lives.
In Plain Sight was presented by Once Off Productions and NB Theatre with support of Backstage Theatre and took place in Castle Varagh Hotel, Castlepollard. It was staged last Friday night (November 13) and Saturday afternoon (November 14).